Fidelity mySmart Cash v. Schwab High Yield Checking

I'm currently debating moving my primary checking account - the two alternatives I am deciding between are the Schwab High Yield Checking and the Fidelity mySmart Cash account. While I'm not sure which account I'm going to go with yet, I decided to post the pros and cons (as I see them) of each for other people who may be unhappy with their current checking options.

Schwab High Yield Checking

The Schwab High Yield Checking is a relatively new offering from Schwab. The account is basically a standard FDIC insured free checking account, but offers more perks than your average local bank. The account offers no fees, zero minimum balance, ATM fee refunds, a variable APY now hovering around 3.01%, free checks, a free check card, and a free brokerage account.

Fidelity mySmart Cash

The Fidelity myCash account is similarly a fairly new offering from Fidelity. mySmart Cash is a cash management account that operates as a quasi-checking account. A client opens a mySmart cash account and links it to a current Fidelity offering (like a money market fund). The mySmart cash account has no minimum balance requirement, no fees, ATM fee reimbursement, free checks, and free self-funded overdraft protection. The client is free to withdraw funds at an ATM or write a check on the account regardless of the balance, Fidelity will then move the appropriate amount from the designated account to cover the balance if the mySmart cash accounthas insufficient funds.

Comparison

Outside of a few minor differences the offerings from Fidelity and Schwab are pretty similar. However, there are a few relatively major differences that may contribute to the decision for some people. First, Schwab currently offers a higher APY on its checking account. However, this is probably offset by the fact that the mySmart cash account can be set to automatically draw from a higher yielding account (like a money market or mutual fund). A second difference is that the Schwab account comes standard with a free brokerage account. If you aren't already set up with a brokerage account then this may be an advantage to you - especially since the brokerage account has no minimum balance or opening amount. Below I have made a quick chart to show the features of both accounts, you'll see that they are pretty similar. I have a feeling that for most people the decision to chose one of these accounts would be based on whether they currently have a Fidelity or Schwab holdings already.


Do you find either of these accounts compelling? Do you already have one? Let us know how you like it.

Link: Schwab High Yield Checking

Link: Fidelity mySmart Cash

ATM Fee Hikes On Horizon

As consumer banks look to juice returns during a down period for new loans and mortgages be on the watch for rising ATM fees. In certain areas of the country JP Morgan, Bank of America and Wachovia have started charging $3 for non-account holders. Add that to the $1 or more that many banks like Chase already charge consumers themselves for the use of ATM’s not natively owned by the bank and consumers are getting a raw deal. You may be getting charged up to 20% of your withdrawal if you are making a withdrawal of $20 for example.

The average ATM fee today is $1.78, but five years ago it was about $1 at a bank where you didn’t have an account. My response, switch to a bank that refunds ATM fees that other institutions charge…. or if that isn’t a practical option for you use a point of sale cash back option – there are Walgreens and Wal-marts everywhere and a pack of gum costs a lot less than a $4 ATM fee.

If you are in the market for a checking account that has ATM refunds, some possibilities with decent interest are

Schwab High Yield Checking: 3.21% APY Variable with no min.

E*Trade: 3.60% APY Variable with $5,000 min.

Readers, do you have other suggestions? Comments?

Link to story @ ABC News

Image: wrestlingentropy @ Flickr

How Healthy Is Your Bank

I stumbled across an interesting page on Bankrate.com today. Using what they call their "Safe & Sound" system you can look up your bank and see generally how its financial stability is compared to its peers. If you have your money in an insured account such as a FDIC savings account or SIPC brokerage account and are under the insured limits you don't have much to worry about -- however, it's still interesting to see how your bank fares.

Ratings are broken down as follows:

Safe & Sound CAEL rating system

Safe & Sound CAEL rating Definition Star rating 1 Superior ««««« 2 Sound «««« 3 Performing ««« 4 Below peer group «« 5 Lowest rated « No Report Complete data not available No Report "U" Closed Institution is closed Closed G Designates high growth --

Image by: PixelJones @ Flickr

If Banks Were People... Which Would Be a Deadbeat Dad?

Okay, so it's far from scientific, but if you are interested in marketing or branding this poll might be worth a look. Currently in the lead for the hypothetical deadbeat is Bank of America. You can get in on the action and vote too if you want here.

I'm going to guess that BOA is overpaying some consulting marketing guru's as I type this. This is one time where it isn't the marketer's fault. I doubt a marketing VP decided that it would be a great PR move to get entangled in the very polarizing illegal immigration debate.